It seems everyone has a different idea on what exploiting is, and what isn't considered an exploit. The dictionary definition of exploiting is different than the way most players interpret it in a MMORPG.
Exploiting to me is pretty cut, and dry.
If you are playing the game just like the other players, and you figure something out I don't consider it exploiting. I figure the players actually used problem solving skills to figure out a viable strategy. They should be rewarded, and not punished.
I know many people said it became exploiting when they sent the rogue in there several times to test it out. How is that exploiting? Isn't that just seeing if your strategy will work before using it in your raid?
If achievements were not in the game would have Blizzard taken the same action? I think it would have been handled differently. Do you really treat your best players like they did? I think Blizzard owes them an apology.
I think exploiting is using outside programs to change how your character reacts in the game. I am not talking about authorized addons, but programs like Warbuddy, Radar, or Aimbots. These programs to me are actually what an exploit is. You are giving your character abilities that can't be achieved with normal gameplay, and giving you a competitive advantage that other players can't do.
Exploiting is being able to walk through walls, triple your health bar, double your damage, find enemies, one shot headkill players. If it is only achievable with an extra program running in the background of your computer while you play than it is definitely exploiting.
